Laser Curing of Powder Coatings
Laser curing offers a precise, energy-efficient alternative to traditional convection ovens, reducing environmental impact in powder coating processes. Read the full article for more information.
A Step Towards Greener and more Economical Production
New applications for diode lasers are not always the result of radical innovations. Often enough, they arise from the transfer of technical concepts originally intended for completely different applications. A current example is the laser curing of powder coatings. It uses ultra wide spot beam technology developed for drying battery electrodes and, as with battery drying, is competing with heat treatment in convection ovens.
Powder coating has been a common method of component coating for decades. It is usually used for color application or corrosion protection – often both combined – and is often used for flat metal components such as sheets, panels, lamellae or garage doors. They are characterized by high chemical and mechanical resistance and are significantly more stable overall than wet paint finishes, for example. However, the coating process, which is technically established but is increasingly proving to be uneconomical and ecologically questionable in essential parts, causes difficulties. Accordingly, there is great interest in concepts for process optimization within the industry. Diode lasers, as much is already apparent, could play an important role in this.
Nowadays, powder coating of metal components is routinely carried out using processes of electrodynamics and heat treatment. The electrodynamics are used to initially create a basic bond between the component and the powder material. Before the powder particles are sprayed onto the component, they are electrostatically charged in the spray gun – usually with the help of an electrode at the tip of the gun (known as a corona application). The component is grounded in advance and then attracts the sprayed particles due to the charge difference. The result is a loosely adhering powder layer that is stable for several hours. At this point, the heat treatment process begins: the component and the powder layer are heated together to approx. 180°C, causing the molecular structures of the powder to cross-link. It melts and turns into a gel-like state until finally the entire surface to be coated is covered by a coating. The temperature is then kept constant and the coating cures through continued molecular cross-linking to create the finished powder coating.
Heat Treatment in a Convection Oven as the Weak Point of the Process
Recently, precisely this final heat treatment has increasingly emerged as the Achilles' heel of the entire process. Until now, it has usually been carried out in a gas-fired convection oven, which raises questions in view of the development of gas prices and the CO2 balance of fossil fuels alone. The fact that the oven process consumes as much energy as all the other steps of the coating process combined is an even more significant factor. Moreover, the ratio between throughput and energy consumption is so unfavorable that it is difficult to call it an economically viable process, not to mention the environmental concerns. This economic-ecological process deficit has several reasons: Since gelling in the convection oven requires thorough heating of the part to be coated, particularly with thick metal sheets, a long heating-up time must be accepted. As a result, the parts remain in the oven for up to 40 minutes, with corresponding negative effects on the energy balance. In addition, the long oven time reduces the throughput rate, which is also affected by the oven's air flow. Since this can stir up some of the electrostatically adhering particles, causing a powder flight, large distances between the components must be maintained during loading. Otherwise, there is a risk of critical contamination by different colored particles, especially with color coatings. Even this measure only partially protects against the risk of defects: If the oven process needs to be stopped unplanned – for example, due to a technical malfunction — the thermal inertia of the oven can lead to overheating of the coatings, potentially rendering the parts unusable.
Considering these disadvantages of the oven process, many observers now agree that the path to an ecological and economically viable powder coating process lies in exploring alternative methods of heat treatment. This applies especially to the heating phase, which, compared to other process steps, consumes the most energy and also presents the greatest risk of powder drift. It is precisely in this area that an alternative solution is urgently needed—one that optimizes energy consumption and allows for more precise heat treatment by preventing critical powder flight.
Diode Laser with Ultra Wide Spot as a Convincing Alternative
With the initially mentioned curing using diode lasers, this alternative solution is now also available. The relatively new process uses the Ultra Wide Spot technology, which was originally developed by Laserline for the electrode drying of lithium-ion batteries in the roll-to-roll process. This beam technology is based on the specially designed OTX Ultra Wide Spot Optics and makes it possible to realize beam widths of 1.5 meters and more. This makes it interesting for other heat treatment processes of large surfaces beyond electrode drying. When curing powder coatings, this beam technology can be applied either for both the heating and holding phases – covering the entire curing process – or just for the heating phase. In the latter case, laser curing is used before the oven process, handling the melting and gelling, while the holding phase continues unchanged in the oven.
The major advantage of curing with diode lasers is the precise and disruption-free energy input: While the entire component is heated during the oven process – and this is done by an air flow that proves to be disadvantageous for high throughput rates – a comparatively “cold” process is realized during laser curing: The precisely sized Ultra Wide Spot ensures that only the area that is actually to be coated is heated, without stirring up particles. The full output power of the laser is available immediately and is adjusted within milliseconds during the process: a closed-loop control system using a pyrometer that continuously measures the surface temperature of the treated area and adjusts the power of the laser accordingly ensures both seamless process control and the correct energy input. In the heating phase, this process design allows a 90 percent increase in the heating rate, which significantly reduces the component exposure time. Since the large-area laser beam does not cause powder flight, a more tightly controlled heat treatment and thus a significant increase in throughput rates is possible. Finally, the constant temperature control prevents the coating from being over-fired. If the component throughput must be stopped completely, the laser can be switched off in milliseconds and the energy input reduced to zero – except for an uncritical residual heat in the surrounding air, which is due to the radiation of process heat.
Transition via Hybrid Processes Likely
Laser curing thus offers industrial users a process option that eliminates all critical moments, especially in the heating phase, and proves to be an economically and ecologically convincing alternative to conventional oven processes. In addition, the use of the purely electricity-based diode laser has a fundamental process advantage. With a wall plug efficiency of more than 50 percent, it has the highest energy efficiency of all industrial lasers and contributes to climate protection. In terms of the dimensions of the parts to be coated, there are no industrially relevant limitations, as the Laserline OTX Ultra Wide Spot optics can accommodate all common part sizes. This flexibility also benefits hybrid processes, where the diode laser is used in combination with a convection oven, with the laser positioned before the oven. In these cases, the size of the component is only limited by the dimensions of the oven system. Hybrid processes of this kind are likely to be the norm initially, as they allow existing oven systems to continue operating while simultaneously taking advantage of the new technology. In particular, the more precise heat treatment provided by laser curing directly benefits the oven process as well. Since there is no longer a risk of powder flight after the gelling phase, the higher feed rate achieved during the heating phase can also be applied to the holding phase in the convection oven. The new process not only optimizes its own advantages but also enhances the efficiency of the oven process, thereby contributing to improvements in both economic viability and environmental impact.